The Freedom to Hate
As sectarian violence lashes Burma, the media are using their new-founded freedom for destructive ends.
BY HANNA HINDSTROM | JUNE 14, 2012
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2012/06/14/the_freedom_to_hate
This week's brutal religious violence in Burma's western Arakan state has cast a shadow on the country's democratic progress. Dozens of people have been killed and hundreds of homes destroyed as Buddhists and Rohingya Muslims clash near the Bangladeshi border in the country's worst sectarian violence in decades.
But even more shocking than the violence itself has been the public outpour of vitriol aimed at the Rohingya, the stateless minority group at the center of the conflict. Considered "illegal Bengali immigrants" by the government, they are denied citizenship and are widely despised within Burmese society. Anti-Rohingya views have swept both social and mainstream media, seemingly uniting politicians, human rights activists, journalists, and civil society from across Burma's myriad ethnic groups.
"The so-called Rohingya are liars," tweeted one pro-democracy group. "We must kill all the kalar," said another social media user. (Kalar is a racial slur applied to dark-skinned people from the Indian subcontinent.) Burmese refugees, who themselves have fled persecution, gathered at embassies across the world to protest the "terrorist" Rohingya invading their homeland. Even the prominent student leader Ko Ko Gyi, who played a key role in the 1988 democratic uprising, lambasted them as imposters and frauds.
No doubt Burma's nascent media freedom has played a key role in stirring religious tensions. Vast swathes of inflammatory misinformation are circulating inside Burma -- with mainstream media largely accusing Al Qaeda and "illegal Bengali terrorists" for staging the violence in a bid to spread Islam in Asia. Many allege that the Rohingya are burning their own houses in a bid for attention.
One paper published a graphic photo of the corpse of Thida Htwe, the Buddhist woman whose rape and murder allegedly by three Muslim men instigated the violence, prompting President Thein Sein to suspend the publication under Burma's censorship laws. These are the same papers that in recent months have openly criticized the government for the first time since a nominally civilian administration took over last year.
Ironically, this freedom has also led to a virulent backlash against foreign and exile media, who have reported on the plight of the Rohingya -- described by the UN as one of the most persecuted groups in the world. A leading national paper, The Weekly Eleven News Journal, has launched a campaign against exile media for their coverage of the crisis.
"Foreign media are now presenting bias [sic] reports on the clashes between Rakhine people and Bengali Rohingyas to destroy the image of Myanmar [Burma's official name -- ed.] and its people," warned Eleven Media Group in a statement. "Only Rohingyas killed Rakhine people and burned down their houses." Earlier this week they denounced New York Times reporter Thomas Fuller for citing hateful comments made against Rohingyas on their website.
While anti-Rohingya sentiments are not new to Burma, the attacks have taken on a more urgent and egregious nature with greater access to information. In November last year, a social media campaign whipped up a tirade of animosity against the BBC for a report (published one year earlier) that had identified the Rohingya as residents of Arakan state.
In the wake of the latest violence, a number of online campaigns have been set up to coordinate attacks against news outlets that dare to report on their plight. Angry protesters rallied in Rangoon this week, brandishing signs reading "Bengali Broadcast Corporation" and "Desperate Voice of Bengali." The latter was a reference to my employer, the Democratic Voice of Burma, the Norway-based broadcaster that has made a name for itself among many Burmese as one of the most reliable sources of information about their country. This weekend DVB faced the biggest cyber-attack on its website in the organization's history, while its Facebook page is still under constant assault from people issuing threats and posting racist material. It is not without irony that an organization once hailed as a vehicle for free speech has become the target of censorship by the very people it sought to give a voice.
As International Crisis Group explains, the violence is both a consequence of, and threat to, Burma's political transition. However, what they wrongly assume is that the "irresponsible, racist, and inflammatory language" circulating on the internet is likely to be resolved through discussion in the national media. The few balanced voices -- let alone those representing the stateless minority -- are vastly outnumbered by news outlets spouting simplistic, anti-Muslim rhetoric.
The ongoing crisis illustrates the need for Burma to embrace not only independent, but also responsible and inclusive journalism. In order to facilitate this transition, the government must take concrete steps to address the underlying dispute surrounding the Rohingya. The sheer level of racism against them in Burmese society -- enforced by a government policy of discrimination and abuse -- lies at the core of the matter.
This week, a politician from the military-backed USDP party called for a "King Dragon Operation" -- a 1978 military operation run by dictator Ne Win to stamp out the Rohingya population from Northern Arakan state. Meanwhile, reports of army complicity in attacks on Muslim homes are growing after a state of emergency was declared on Sunday. Immigration minister Khin Yi has again reiterated that "there are no Rohingya in Burma," while Aung San Suu Kyi's National League for Democracy continues to carefully sidestep the hot-button issue as she begins her global tour. State media has also fanned tensions by using the racial slur kalar in their official appeal for calm after ten Muslim pilgrims were murdered to avenge Thida Htwe's death.
While the government has taken ostensible steps to calm the violence -- including publishing a retraction for the racial slur -- it is far from sufficient. Nor is invoking draconian censorship laws a viable solution. There must be a rational public debate on the future of the Rohingya minority in Burma.
The issue is both sensitive and complex, but it cannot be ignored. Political leaders, especially Thein Sein and Aung San Suu Kyi, along with the international community, have an obligation to drive this process. Failure to do so threatens to unravel Burma's democratic reform at a time when it cannot afford to regress.
Hanna Hindstrom is a journalist with the Democratic Voice of Burma based in Thailand.
Unique
My Blog List
HITS
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Followers
Blog Archive
-
▼
2012
(5887)
-
▼
June
(689)
- Bull Shit Marxist Ideology!The Marxists Committed ...
- अभी मंहगाई की मार कहां पड़ी है? गैर राजनीतिक गैर ...
- BOOKS: EXTRACT The Night Shastri Died And Other St...
- Grrr over GAAR and then purr Hint of course correc...
- CM takes Left on board in debt-relief fight Foe sa...
- हिन्दू फासीवाद का हिडेन एजेण्डा By राम पुनियानी 27...
- कलाम का सलाम सोनिया के नाम
- गोली मारने के बाद यहां स्कूली बच्चे भी माओवादी बना...
- बाजार तो उठा पर, आम आदमी को मिलेगा क्या?
- Nitish-Modi Spat: Debating Secularism
- Justice Sachar Committee Report Findings CPI(M)’s ...
- Sachar Committee Report
- Sachar Committee Report
- Sachar Committee From Wikipedia, the free encyclop...
- सच्चर रिपोर्ट सरकार को सौंपी गई
- फुटबाल टूर्नामेंट, सानिया मिर्जा और नैनीताल!
- सच्चर कमेटी की सिफारिशें और कार्यान्वयन
- सच्चर कमेटी की रिपोर्ट और मुसलमान
- Baba aur Shobhakantji ke saath meri aur Savita ki ...
- उद्योग जगत को स्टिमुलस देने का पक्का इंतजाम,गार का...
- FM Manmohan Makes Investor Richer by Rs 1.17 trill...
- Fwd: [New post] अर्थ के अनर्थ की तहकीकात
- Fwd: Michel Chossudovsky: The US-NATO Military Cru...
- Fwd: [New post] पश्चिम एशिया : फिलिस्तीन के यहूदीक...
- Fwd: Today's Exclusives - Indian stocks shoot up a...
- Fwd: [Please vote Lenin Raghuvanshi as reconciliat...
- Fwd: Debating Secularism ISP IV June 2012
- Fwd: [New post] अर्थजगत : नव उदारवाद और विकास के अ...
- Fwd: कृपया सम्बंधित विषय पर नई -नई जानकारियों के स...
- Fwd: [Please vote Lenin Raghuvanshi as reconciliat...
- Fwd: आणा -पखाणा अर राजनीति
- Fwd: Jagadishwar Chaturvedi updated his status: "य...
- Fwd: (हस्तक्षेप.कॉम) आतंकवाद के नाम पर पकड़े गए बे...
- मनमोहन ने पहले ही दिन डंके की चोट पर बाजार का जय...
- यूरोकप, पुलिनबाबू मेमोरियल फुटबाल टूर्नामेंट, सानि...
- देशद्रोह कैदियों के पक्ष में लखनऊ में धरना
- 'कविता तय करेगी, बल्ली बिक गया या निखर आया'
- जंगल में कोसी कहीं हंस रही होगी !
- Sinking Into Murky Water With Russia By Raminder Kaur
- Upper caste youths stop dalit's ghurchari
- To Be or Not To Be By Peter G Cohen
- An open letter to RSS Sarsanghchalak, Shri Mohan B...
- Surjeet Singh crosses over to India after 31 years...
- Unarmed major who disarmed Pak soldiers and saved ...
- Pranab Mukherjee files nomination for Presidential...
- SBI cuts interest rate for exporters by half a per...
- Govt takes back 3 mines from utilities, and asks C...
- সিঙ্গুর কাণ্ড, পঞ্চায়েত আইন সংশোধন নিয়ে বিতর্কে সু...
- প্রাকৃতিক বিপর্যয়ে নিহত শতাধিক বাংলাদেশ
- রাষ্ট্রপতি পদে মনোনয়ন পেশ প্রণব-সাংমার, অনুপস্থিত ...
- यशवंत सिन्हा ने किया समर्पण, जमानत मिली
- संगमा ने राष्ट्रपति पद के लिए नामांकन दाखिल किया
- दिग्गजों की मौजूदगी में राष्ट्रपति चुनाव के लिए प्...
- भारत में ज्यादातर राजनीतिक दल ‘‘सामंती’’ बन गए हैं...
- अमेरिकी अदालत ने भोपाल गैस कांड में यूनियन कार्बाइ...
- अबु जंदल की पहचान पर उठ रहें सवाल
- Fwd: Inhuman torture by BSF upon a DALIT and subse...
- यूरोकप, पुलिनबाबू मेमोरियल फुटबाल टूर्नामेंट, सानि...
- तो प्याज की परतें खुलने लगी हैं कि हवाओं में तापदा...
- Fwd: [All India Secular Forum] Report of the Gujar...
- Fwd: Fire in Mantralaya.....
- Fwd: [Buddhist Friends] "The Hindutva forces - Rag...
- Fwd: [New post] एड्रिएन रिच की कविताएं
- Fwd: Poorest people bail out some of the richest -...
- Fwd: कुरेड़ी फटेगी ; कथा संग्रह गढवाली कथा माल़ा क...
- Fwd: (हस्तक्षेप.कॉम) हिन्दुत्व नहीं है, हिन्दू धर्म
- Fwd: [New post] घटनाक्रम : जून 2012
- Fwd: रिहाई(?) ने बताई मीडिया की सच्चाई
- Fwd: [New post] पत्र : अंग्रेजी का कमाल
- Fwd: भग्यान अबोध बंधु बहुगुणा क दगड भीष्म कुकरेती ...
- Fwd: [samakalika malayalam vaarikha] http://kerala...
- Fwd: Raghuvanshi: BJP manipulates Christian candid...
- Fwd: [विश्वप्रसिद्ध टेलीफिल्म ‘रूट्स’ का प्रदर्शन]...
- Appease Feuding Mail Champion Duo of Indian Tennis...
- प्रणव के विदा होते ही रिलायंस इंडस्ट्रीज ने शर्त ल...
- Pranab`s Exit from North Block exposes the Bottoml...
- Pulin Babu Memorial Football Tournament uttarakhand
- Re: Subscribe now for Rs. 500
- Fwd: [ASMITA THEATRE GROUP ( ASMITA ART GROUP, Del...
- Fwd: TaraChandra Tripathi shared देवसिंह रावत's photo
- नीतीश-मोदी विवाद: धर्मनिरपेक्षता पर बहस का सबब -रा...
- विदा होते वित्तमंत्री प्रणव का देश को अबाध विदेशी ...
- Fwd: [Nainital Lovers] नैनी झील में माइनस में जल स...
- Fwd: [New post] नैट पर समयांतर : www.samayantar.com
- Fwd: क्या आप दैनिक गढवाली -कुमाउनी समाचार पत्र हेत...
- Fwd: [PVCHR] New Event Invite: Observing Internati...
- Fwd: [National Consultation :Testimonial campaign ...
- Fwd: Tony Cartalucci: CONFIRMED - US CIA Arming Te...
- Fwd: Today's Exclusives - Cement Cartel: A lesson ...
- अलविदा प्रणव दा
- कश्मीर में खिली उम्मीद की कली
- शून्य शिखर पर कुछ ना सूझै
- मुसीबत बन गया मातृ संगठन
- ‘जनता के दोस्त थे तरुण शेहरावत’
- मलबा बन के रह गई है भीमताल की झील
- राष्ट्रपति चुनाव या 2014 का 'सेमीफाईनल'
- Rape victim's kin torch houses of five accused, ad...
- Documentary on Hindu Rashtra
- THE HARD TIMES MUST GO - India needs drastic refor...
- Finally, feels like monsoon Season’s wettest & coo...
-
▼
June
(689)
No comments:
Post a Comment